
Hotel Jane
Best for travelers who want a convenient, budget-conscious base within walking distance of Florence’s historic center.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Jane is a practical, 3-star city hotel in Florence’s Santa Croce/Saude area aimed at travelers who want a simple, walkable base. Collegio alla Querce, Auberge Collection is a five-star, resort-style Auberge Collection property for guests looking for luxury facilities (pool, spa, restaurants) while still within Florence.
Updated

Best for travelers who want a convenient, budget-conscious base within walking distance of Florence’s historic center.

Best for guests who want five-star service and on-site amenities (outdoor pool, spa, multiple restaurants) while staying in Florence.
When Hotel Jane wins: choose Hotel Jane if you want a straightforward, well-located 3-star hotel near Santa Croce that welcomes families and pets, is outside the ZTL for easier driving, and keeps costs and extras simple.
When Collegio alla Querce, Auberge Collection wins: pick Collegio alla Querce when you want a five-star, resort-style stay in Florence with an outdoor seasonal pool, on-site spa treatments, several restaurants/bars and a full-service luxury experience.
Bottom line: Hotel Jane is a compact, practical city hotel for sightseers and families on a moderate budget. Collegio alla Querce is a higher-end choice for guests who prioritize on-site amenities and a resort-style stay in Florence.
| Category | Hotel Jane | Collegio alla Querce, Auberge Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Simple, practical city hotel | Five-star, resort-style luxury |
| Location (neighborhood) | Santa Croce / Saude (near Porta alla Croce) | Le Cure (Florence) |
| Size | Small (about 24–34 rooms depending on source) | Mid-large (83 guestrooms listed) |
| Ages / audience | All ages; family- and pet-friendly | All ages; not adults-only |
| Pools | No pool | Outdoor seasonal pool (May–September) and poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Bar/lounge and paid buffet breakfast; restaurant listing is inconsistent across OTAs | Two restaurants, bar/lounge, poolside bar, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & fitness | No spa or fitness centre | On-site spa treatment rooms and 24-hour fitness/health club |
| Transport & parking | Outside ZTL; paid on-site/self parking and EV charging; no consistent airport transfer | Limited on-site parking (valet available for a surcharge), complimentary area shuttle within 2.5 km |
| Known for | Walkable access to Duomo, Santa Croce; pet- and family-friendly low-key base | International Auberge Collection branding, resort facilities, spa and pool |
| Wi‑Fi | Free Wi‑Fi in rooms and public areas | |
Hotel Jane sits in the Santa Croce/Saude area, close to Porta alla Croce and within walking distance of Florence’s main sights.
A convenient base for sightseeing on foot, especially if you prefer to drive or arrive by car.
Collegio alla Querce is in the Le Cure neighborhood of Florence and positions itself as a luxury resort-style Auberge Collection property.
A luxury property that’s slightly removed from the immediate historic-core walking zone but offers shuttle and valet options.
Hotel Jane offers compact, practical rooms in several small categories suitable for solo travelers, couples and families.
Rooms are straightforward and aimed at travelers who prioritize location and value over in-room luxury.
Collegio alla Querce lists a broad set of room categories from Classic rooms to suites and a penthouse.
A wide range of room options and suite choices for guests seeking upgraded space and amenities.
Hotel Jane provides a small on-site bar and a paid buffet breakfast option.
If you want straightforward drinks and a paid breakfast buffet, Hotel Jane covers the basics; for more variety you'll rely on nearby restaurants.
Collegio alla Querce lists multiple on-site dining options and 24-hour room service.
Stronger on-site dining options and service for guests who want meals and evening drinks without leaving the property.
Hotel Jane does not offer a pool or pool-area facilities.
No pool — choose this hotel for walking and sightseeing, not on-site swimming.
Collegio alla Querce provides a seasonal outdoor pool and related pool amenities.
The outdoor pool is a key part of the Auberge Collection experience here — good for guests wanting resort-style downtime in Florence.
Hotel Jane has no spa or fitness centre; nightlife options are primarily nearby bars and restaurants in the city.
Expect limited on-site wellness or nightlife; the city provides most options within walking distance.
Collegio alla Querce offers on-site spa services and a 24-hour health club for fitness-minded guests.
Better if you want on-site spa and fitness facilities and a more self-contained stay.

Hotel Jane — close to the Duomo and other sights, walkable and more budget-friendly.

Collegio alla Querce — pool, spa, multiple restaurants and Auberge Collection service.

Hotel Jane — explicitly family- and pet-friendly and smaller, simpler rooms.

Collegio alla Querce — resort orientation and a wider range of room types and suites.
Hotel Jane is within a 15–25 minute walk to the Duomo and other central sights; Collegio alla Querce is a short drive from the center and offers a complimentary shuttle within 2.5 km.
Collegio alla Querce has an outdoor seasonal pool and on-site spa treatment rooms; Hotel Jane does not have a pool or spa.
Yes — both properties are not adults-only. Hotel Jane highlights family-friendly and pet-friendly services; Collegio alla Querce is also open to all ages.
Hotel Jane sits outside the ZTL and lists paid self-parking and EV charging; Collegio alla Querce has limited on-site parking with a valet option (surcharge).
Explore how Hotel Jane stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·