
Hotel Jane
Best for travelers who want a simple, family- and pet-friendly base outside Florence's ZTL with easy car access and straightforward services.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Jane is a straightforward 3-star, family- and pet-friendly hotel near Porta alla Croce for travelers who want easy car access and basic, reliable city lodgings. Donati Luxury Tower Suites is a small collection of high-end suites inside a historic Florentine tower near the Duomo—read this if you want central, upscale rooms with private spa-style features and skyline views.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want a simple, family- and pet-friendly base outside Florence's ZTL with easy car access and straightforward services.

Best for guests seeking central, luxury suites with heated floors, private jacuzzis/saunas and direct proximity to the Duomo.
When Hotel Jane wins: choose Hotel Jane if you need an all-ages option that accepts pets, offers on-site parking and an affordable, no-frills base for sightseeing and day trips around Tuscany.
When Donati Luxury Tower Suites wins: choose Donati if you want a small, high-end suite with Duomo views, in-room spa features (jacuzzi/private sauna options), and a very central historic-tower address steps from Florence’s main sights.
Bottom line: Hotel Jane is a practical, family- and driver-friendly 3-star pick outside the ZTL; Donati Luxury Tower Suites is a boutique, 5-star choice for travelers prioritizing location and in-suite luxury over on-site leisure facilities.
| Category | Hotel Jane | Donati Luxury Tower Suites |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Friendly, practical 3-star city hotel | Small luxury suites in a historic tower |
| Location (centrality) | Santa Croce / Porta alla Croce; 15–25 min walk to Duomo | Steps from Piazza del Duomo and Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore |
| Size | About 28 rooms (sources vary) | 12 air-conditioned rooms (supplier listing) |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; family- and pet-friendly | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Parking & ZTL access | On-site/nearby paid parking, outside ZTL (car-friendly) | Valet/self parking available for a surcharge; central location likely inside ZTL |
| Pools | No pool | No published pool; many suites include private jacuzzis or spa features |
| Restaurants & bars | 24-hour bar/lounge; buffet breakfast available for a surcharge | No on-site signature restaurant published; concierge and room comforts highlighted |
| Wellness / spa | No spa or fitness center on site | Private spa facilities in some suites (jacuzzi, Private Sauna, Private Jacuzzi® listed) |
| Known for | Good basic service, garden breakfast room, pet-friendly touches | Historic tower setting, Duomo views and luxury suite amenities |
| Free Wi‑Fi | Yes, in rooms and public areas | |
Hotel Jane sits in Santa Croce near Porta alla Croce, outside Florence’s ZTL with easier car access.
Hotel Jane is better if you want easier driving access and a quieter residential location a short walk from the historic centre.
Donati Luxury Tower Suites is in Piazza Santa Elisabetta, steps from Florence’s Duomo and central attractions.
Donati’s location is ideal if you want to be in the very heart of Florence and next to the Duomo.
Hotel Jane offers straightforward room types and practical amenities for families and groups.
Hotel Jane is functional and family-oriented, with multiple room sizes but without in-room spa features.
Donati Luxury Tower Suites lists multiple named suites with Duomo views and in-suite spa amenities.
Donati focuses on a small number of high-end suites with in-room spa features and premium finishes.
Hotel Jane provides a small on-site bar and a paid buffet breakfast; full restaurant options are limited.
Expect a reliable breakfast service and an always-open bar rather than multiple on-site restaurants.
Donati’s listing highlights concierge services and in-suite comforts; no signature on-site restaurant is published in the supplier listing.
Donati prioritizes luxury suites and location; dining is likely via nearby central restaurants rather than an on-site dining program.
Hotel Jane does not offer a pool or on-site spa; it focuses on city-stay essentials.
Hotel Jane is a city hotel for sightseeing, not for on-site leisure amenities like pools or spas.
Donati does not list a public pool, but many suites include private spa features and jacuzzis.
Donati replaces public leisure facilities with private in-suite spa features in several rooms.
Hotel Jane offers a relaxed bar and is situated in a residential area with local evening options.
Hotel Jane suits travelers who prefer a calm base with easy access to local nightlife and bars within walking distance.
Donati’s central setting puts guests within walking distance of Florence’s main evening attractions.
Donati is more convenient if you want immediate access to Florence’s central evening scene or prefer in-suite relaxation.

Hotel Jane welcomes families and pets and offers a range of multi-bed rooms and practical services.

Donati features suites with private jacuzzis, spa baths and direct Duomo views in a historic tower.

Hotel Jane sits outside the ZTL with on-site/nearby paid parking and an EV charging option.

Donati places you literally steps from Florence’s cathedral and major central sights.
Hotel Jane — it is family- and pet-friendly with multi-bed room types; Donati is a luxury-suite property but not adults-only.
No public pool is published for either property. Donati offers private in-suite jacuzzis/spa features in many suites.
Donati Luxury Tower Suites is immediately adjacent to the Duomo; Hotel Jane is about a 15–25 minute walk away.
Hotel Jane sits outside the ZTL and lists on-site/nearby paid parking and EV charging. Donati offers valet/self parking for a surcharge but is in the central area where ZTL rules may apply.
Explore how Hotel Jane stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·