
Hotel Jane
Best for travelers who want a simple, well-located Florentine stay with pet- and family-friendly policies and lower rates.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Jane is a modest 3-star, family- and pet-friendly Florence base with a garden breakfast room and a 24-hour bar; read this if you want a practical, budget-conscious stay near the historic center. The Excelsior, a Luxury Collection Hotel, Florence is a grand 5-star riverside luxury hotel with rooftop dining and river views; read this if you want central, full-service luxury and scenic panoramas of the Arno.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want a simple, well-located Florentine stay with pet- and family-friendly policies and lower rates.

Best for travelers who want full 5-star services, river views, rooftop dining, and a central luxury address near Ponte Vecchio.
When Hotel Jane wins: choose Hotel Jane if you want a straightforward, affordable Florence base that welcomes families and pets, sits outside the ZTL for easier car access, and offers a garden breakfast room and 24-hour bar.
When The Excelsior wins: choose The Excelsior if you want 5-star amenities, riverside views, rooftop dining at Cosimo Rooftop Restaurant, concierge and transfer services, and a central location within easy walking distance of Santa Maria Novella and the Ponte Vecchio.
Bottom line: Hotel Jane is a practical choice for budget-conscious, family or pet travelers who prioritize location outside the ZTL; The Excelsior is a fit for travelers looking for classic five-star luxury, river views, and full-service hotel facilities.
| Category | Hotel Jane | The Excelsior, a Luxury Collection Hotel, Florence |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Modest, practical 3-star city hotel | Grand 5-star riverside luxury hotel |
| Location (landmark distance) | Santa Croce / Porta alla Croce; 15–25 minute walk to Duomo | Piazza Ognissanti on the Arno; ~9-minute walk to Ponte Vecchio |
| Size (rooms) | Small — listed around 24–34 rooms across sources | 171 guestrooms (individually decorated) |
| Ages / audience | All ages; family- and pet-friendly | All ages (not adults-only); family-friendly services and babysitting available |
| Pools | No pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Breakfast room (buffet for a surcharge) and 24-hour bar/lounge | Cosimo Rooftop Restaurant, 2 bars/lounges, 24-hour room service; breakfast available for a fee |
| Spa / wellness | No spa or fitness center on site | Fitness facilities on site; health/beauty spa listed as nearby (not a named on-site spa) |
| Transport & parking | Self parking (surcharge); outside ZTL makes driving easier; no confirmed airport transfer | Airport and train transfers available for a surcharge; valet parking (surcharge) and limo/town car service |
| Known for | Friendly, practical base with garden breakfast room and easy car access | Riverside position near Ponte Vecchio and rooftop dining with city views |
| Accessibility | Wheelchair access not listed as comprehensive; contact hotel for details | Wheelchair-accessible features and paths listed (may have limitations) |
Hotel Jane sits in the Santa Croce/Saude district near Porta alla Croce, outside Florence's ZTL.
A convenient, walkable location that’s easier to reach by car than ZTL-address hotels.
The Excelsior sits on Piazza Ognissanti by the Arno River, close to major central sights.
A central riverside address that’s ideal if you want to be steps from Florence’s core and the Arno.
Hotel Jane offers a small set of simple room types suited to budget-minded travelers and families.
Simple, practical room choices for families, groups, and pet owners.
The Excelsior offers a wide range of individually decorated rooms and suites, many with river views or terraces.
Many larger, feature-rich room and suite options, including river-view and terrace choices.
Hotel Jane keeps dining simple: a paid buffet breakfast and a 24-hour bar/lounge.
Good for basic breakfast and evening drinks; most full-service dining is nearby.
The Excelsior provides multiple on-site dining options, highlighted by a rooftop restaurant and bars.
A better choice if you want on-site fine dining, rooftop meals, and in-house beverage options.
Hotel Jane does not offer a pool or a large signature amenity on site.
No pool — plan activities around city sightseeing and nearby attractions.
The Excelsior emphasizes riverside position and rooftop terrace; pool availability is not published in the supplier listing.
Choose The Excelsior for river views and rooftop dining; details about a pool are not published.
Hotel Jane focuses on practical services and nearby nightlife rather than on-site wellness.
Good for travelers who plan to use city nightlife and day-trip options rather than hotel wellness facilities.
The Excelsior offers more on-site wellness and nightlife options for guests seeking hotel-based services.
Better if you want in-house fitness, concierge-arranged evening plans, and rooftop dining.

Hotel Jane offers lower-category rooms, a modest breakfast option, and practical services that keep costs down.

Hotel Jane explicitly welcomes families and pets and provides pet services and family room options.

The Excelsior provides river-view rooms and Cosimo Rooftop Restaurant for skyline and Arno vistas.

The Excelsior’s 171 individually decorated rooms, concierge, transfer services, and multiple bars suit travelers seeking a classic 5-star stay.
Hotel Jane sits outside Florence's ZTL and offers onsite or nearby paid parking, so it’s simpler to arrive by car.
The Excelsior — it has river-view rooms, terraces, and a rooftop restaurant that suit special-occasion dining and views.
No. Both hotels list breakfast as available for an additional fee rather than included by default.
Hotel Jane is pet-friendly. The Excelsior allows pets for a published fee (per supplier listing) — confirm size and booking details directly with each hotel.
Explore how Hotel Jane stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·