
Hotel Jane
Best for travelers who want simple, budget-conscious rooms, car access and a family- and pet-friendly stay outside the ZTL.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Jane is a modest 3-star, family- and pet-friendly base just outside Florence’s ZTL that suits budget-conscious travelers who want easy car access. The St. Regis Florence is a historic 5-star hotel on the Arno for travelers seeking full-service luxury and a central, polished address.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want simple, budget-conscious rooms, car access and a family- and pet-friendly stay outside the ZTL.

Best for guests who want classic five-star service, river views and on-site luxury amenities in central Florence.
When Hotel Jane wins: If you need a practical, lower-cost base with easy car access (outside the ZTL), pet-friendly rooms and a straightforward location within walking distance of Florence’s sights, Hotel Jane is the better pick.
When The St. Regis Florence wins: If you want historic five-star rooms on the Arno, formal dining at Winter Garden, spa services, and extensive guest services (limo service, meeting rooms, concierge), the St. Regis is the clear choice.
Bottom line: Hotel Jane is a practical, value-minded choice for families, drivers and pet owners who plan to spend most days sightseeing; The St. Regis Florence is for travelers prioritizing luxury, location on the Arno and a fuller on-site amenity set.
| Category | Hotel Jane | The St. Regis Florence |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Practical, budget-friendly city hotel with a casual bar and garden | Historic, formal five-star luxury on the Arno with classic public rooms |
| Location | Santa Croce / Porta alla Croce, outside the ZTL; 15–25 minute walk to the Duomo | Piazza Ognissanti on the Arno; within a 10-minute walk of Ponte Vecchio and Santa Maria Novella |
| Size (rooms) | Not published | 99 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Room types | Standard or Room; Room (Piccola / Small); Economy Room, Balcony; Triple Room; Quadruple Room | Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed; Premium Room, 1 King Bed; Junior Suite, 1 King Bed; Deluxe Suite; Royal Suite; Presidential Suite (river-view options listed) |
| Pools / water features | No pool | No full pool listed; hot tub and steam room available |
| Restaurants & bars | 24-hour bar/lounge; buffet breakfast room (breakfast for a surcharge) | Winter Garden (fine-dining Mediterranean), bar/lounge, 24-hour room service, breakfast (fee) |
| Spa & wellness | No spa or fitness center on site | Spa services on site; steam room and hot tub |
| Parking & transport | On-site self parking for a surcharge; EV charging; outside the ZTL so easy by car | Parking (limited spaces) and covered valet (fee); airport/train transfers (surcharge) |
| Family & pets | Family-friendly and pet-friendly (pets welcome) | All-ages property; pets allowed with a published pet fee |
| Known for / standout | Value, straightforward service, garden and easy car access outside ZTL | Historic St. Regis brand, Arno-front location, Winter Garden restaurant and full luxury services |
Hotel Jane sits in the Santa Croce / Porta alla Croce area outside Florence's ZTL, with many central sights reachable on foot.
Choose Hotel Jane if you want easier driving access to the city and don't need a riverfront address.
The St. Regis Florence sits on Piazza Ognissanti directly on the Arno, a short walk to Ponte Vecchio and major museums.
Choose the St. Regis for a central, walkable location on the river and access to full-service transport options.
Hotel Jane offers small, practical room types aimed at couples, families and budget travelers.
Hotel Jane focuses on simple, flexible room types for cost-conscious and family stays.
The St. Regis Florence provides a wide range of individually decorated rooms and suites, including river-view and signature suites.
St. Regis suits guests who want formal, well-equipped rooms and upscale suite options, often with river views.
Hotel Jane keeps food and drink simple: a 24-hour bar/lounge plus a buffet breakfast room.
Good for casual drinks and a paid buffet breakfast; most dinner options are nearby local restaurants.
The St. Regis Florence has a signature fine-dining restaurant, bar and 24-hour room service.
Choose St. Regis for formal dining, consistent on-site meal service and a classic hotel restaurant experience.
Hotel Jane does not offer a swimming pool or spa facilities.
Hotel Jane is aimed at sightseeing-focused stays rather than on-site leisure.
The St. Regis provides spa services and wet-area amenities for guest relaxation.
St. Regis adds a small wellness offering and formal indoor leisure spaces to a luxury stay.
Hotel Jane provides a late-night bar and easy access to neighborhood restaurants and bars.
Hotel Jane is suited to guests who plan to go out into the city for nightlife and use the hotel as a convenient base.
The St. Regis supports evening plans with a bar, restaurant and concierge-arranged events or transfers.
St. Regis is better if you want in-house evening dining and concierge help planning nights out.

Hotel Jane offers lower-cost rooms, simple services and easy car access outside the ZTL.

The St. Regis Florence provides Arno-front rooms, a signature restaurant and five-star service.

Hotel Jane is explicitly family- and pet-friendly with pet services and flexible room types.

St. Regis has spa services, meeting rooms, limo/town-car options and more extensive on-site facilities.
The St. Regis Florence is closer—it's on the Arno within a short walk of Ponte Vecchio; Hotel Jane is roughly a 20–25 minute walk.
Yes. Hotel Jane sits outside the ZTL and offers onsite/nearby paid parking and an EV charging station, making it convenient for drivers.
No full swimming pool is listed for The St. Regis Florence; the property lists a hot tub and a steam room.
Hotel Jane is explicitly family- and pet-friendly; The St. Regis accepts pets but charges a fee and is positioned as a full-service luxury hotel.
Explore how Hotel Jane stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·