
Hotel Jane
Best for travelers who want a straightforward, well-located base with low-key service, pet-friendly rooms, and easier car access outside the ZTL.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Jane is a simple, practical 3-star, family- and pet-friendly base near Porta alla Croce/Santa Croce; read this if you want a convenient, budget-conscious stay within walking distance of Florence’s sights. Four Seasons Hotel Firenze is a landmark 5-star garden luxury hotel; read this if you’re comparing an ultra-luxury Florence stay against a straightforward neighborhood option.
Updated · about 1.1 km apart

Best for travelers who want a straightforward, well-located base with low-key service, pet-friendly rooms, and easier car access outside the ZTL.

Best for travelers seeking an iconic, full-service luxury experience in Florence with a large garden, full spa and multiple fine-dining options.
When Hotel Jane wins: choose Hotel Jane if you want a modest 3-star price point, pet- and family-friendly policies, simple practical rooms, and easy car access outside the ZTL.
When Four Seasons Hotel Firenze wins: pick Four Seasons for large, individually furnished rooms and suites, multiple on-site restaurants, a full-service spa, seasonal outdoor pool, and classic high-end service.
Bottom line: Hotel Jane is a practical neighborhood pick for travelers prioritizing location and value; Four Seasons Hotel Firenze is a very different stay — an internationally known, full-service luxury hotel with garden, spa, dining and bigger rooms.
| Category | Hotel Jane | Four Seasons Hotel Firenze |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Simple, residential 3-star; practical services and a garden. | Landmark ultra-luxury 5-star; large historic property with formal gardens. |
| Location (neighborhood) | Santa Croce / Porta alla Croce — outside the ZTL and within 15–25 minute walk to the Duomo. | Central Florence (Borgo Pinti) — within a 15-minute walk of Piazza del Duomo and other main sights. |
| Approx. distance between hotels | Via Orcagna 56/58 (Hotel Jane). | |
| Size (rooms) | Small (about 24–34 rooms depending on source). | 116 individually furnished guestrooms (supplier listing). |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; family- and pet-friendly. | Family-friendly (children allowed) — not adults-only. |
| Pools / outdoor water | No pool on site. | Outdoor seasonal pool (open seasonally; supplier notes May–October). |
| Restaurants & bars | 24-hour bar/lounge and a buffet breakfast room (breakfast for a surcharge). | Three restaurants including Il Palagio, 24-hour room service, bar/lounge and poolside bar. |
| Spa & wellness | No spa or fitness center on site. | Full-service spa with massages, sauna, steam room, fitness facilities and wellness classes. |
| Known for | Practical, accessible base outside the ZTL with parking and EV charging. | Historic garden setting and internationally recognized luxury service. |
| Parking & car access | Self parking for a surcharge; outside ZTL access and EV charging available. | Self and valet parking available (surcharge); on-site uncovered parking noted. |
| Typical traveler | Budget-conscious families, pet owners, drivers who want ZTL access. | Travelers seeking full-service luxury, events, spa and high-end dining. |
Hotel Jane sits in the Santa Croce / Porta alla Croce residential side of the city, outside Florence’s ZTL.
Convenient for walkers who want easier driving access and a quieter neighborhood feel.
Four Seasons Hotel Firenze is in central Florence (Borgo Pinti), within easy walking distance of major sights.
Best if you want to be as central as possible while staying in a large, historic luxury property.
Hotel Jane offers small, practical room types in a compact hotel (room counts vary by source).
Rooms are functional and aimed at practical stays rather than luxury space or finishes.
Four Seasons features 116 individually furnished rooms and suites, many larger and more fully equipped.
Expect larger, more luxurious guestrooms and a wider variety of suite categories and amenities.
Hotel Jane keeps dining straightforward: a buffet breakfast room and a 24-hour bar/lounge.
Good for a casual drink and a paid breakfast; not a hotel for fine-dining options on site.
Four Seasons provides multiple on-site restaurants and full room-service options.
A clear advantage if you want multiple dining choices and high-end restaurant service without leaving the property.
Hotel Jane does not offer a pool.
If a pool matters, Hotel Jane is not the right pick.
Four Seasons has a seasonal outdoor pool and extensive garden spaces.
Four Seasons offers a real on-site pool and extensive outdoor garden space — a major difference from Hotel Jane.
Hotel Jane focuses on basic services rather than wellness facilities.
Good for travelers who will dine out and use Florence for nightlife rather than staying in for wellness.
Four Seasons provides a full-service spa, fitness facilities and more on-site evening options.
Four Seasons is the better pick if on-site wellness and evening hotel amenities are priorities.

Hotel Jane — smaller 3-star rooms and straightforward services make it the budget-friendly choice in this pairing.

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze — large rooms/suites, full spa, gardens and multiple restaurants define a high-end stay.

Hotel Jane — family- and pet-friendly with simple rooms and nearby attractions; good for travelers bringing kids or pets.

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze — seasonal outdoor pool, full spa and fitness facilities make it the clear winner for wellness-focused stays.
Both are within walking distance; Four Seasons is very central (about a 15-minute walk to the Duomo) while Hotel Jane is roughly a 15–25 minute walk depending on pace.
Hotel Jane is pet-friendly. Four Seasons Hotel Firenze accepts pets but a pet fee is published (supplier listing shows a pet fee). Confirm details with the property before booking.
Four Seasons Hotel Firenze has a seasonal outdoor pool and a full-service spa. Hotel Jane does not have a pool or on-site spa.
Yes — Hotel Jane welcomes families and children of all ages; rooms like Triple and Quadruple Room accommodate families.
Explore how Hotel Jane stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·