
Hotel Jane
Best for value-minded travelers who want easy car access, simple comforts, and a relaxed bar and breakfast room.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Jane is a casual, practical 3-star near Porta alla Croce that welcomes families, pets and drivers (outside the ZTL). The Place Firenze is an intimate 5-star boutique on Piazza Santa Maria Novella best for travelers who want a centrally located luxury base close to Florence’s major sights.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for value-minded travelers who want easy car access, simple comforts, and a relaxed bar and breakfast room.

Best for travelers who want a small, luxury boutique stay in the heart of Florence steps from Santa Maria Novella.
When Hotel Jane wins: pick Hotel Jane if you need car-friendly access outside the ZTL, want pet- and family-friendly flexibility, or prefer a straightforward 3-star budget to spend on tours and meals out.
When The Place Firenze wins: choose The Place Firenze if you want a compact five-star boutique experience on Piazza Santa Maria Novella, shorter walks to the Duomo/Ponte Vecchio, and room types that include several suites and penthouses.
Bottom line: Hotel Jane is the practical, lower-cost base with parking and pet policies that suit families and drivers; The Place Firenze is the small luxury option for travelers prioritizing central location and boutique service.
| Category | Hotel Jane | The Place Firenze |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casual, practical 3-star lodging aimed at families and drivers | Intimate, small-scale 5-star boutique hotel focused on luxury and service |
| Location | Santa Croce/Saude near Porta alla Croce; outside the ZTL, 15–25 min walk to Duomo | Piazza di Santa Maria Novella; steps from the basilica and 0.4 mi to Duomo |
| Size | Small — roughly mid-20s to low-30s rooms (sources disagree: 24–34) | 20 guestrooms |
| Room mix (examples) | Standard or Room; Room (Piccola / Small); Economy Room, Balcony; Triple Room; Quadruple Room | The Superior; Double superior; The Deluxe; Double deluxe; The Junior Suite; The Executive Suite; The Santa Maria Novella Master Suite; The Panoramic Loft; Room loft; Penthouse; The duomo penthouse |
| Pools | No pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Breakfast buffet (surcharge), 24-hour bar/lounge; on-site restaurant listing varies by OTA | Restaurant and bar/lounge; room service during limited hours; breakfast available for a fee |
| Spa / wellness | No spa or fitness center on site | Not published |
| Known for | Pet-friendly, on-site parking and EV charging, easy access by car | Central piazza address, boutique luxury, rooftop terrace and suites/penthouses |
| Family / adults policy | All ages welcome (lead guest minimum age policies vary by booking channel) | Family-friendly (not adults-only) |
| Common practicalities | Free Wi‑Fi, 24-hour front desk, luggage storage, paid breakfast | Free Wi‑Fi, 24-hour front desk, concierge, paid breakfast, valet parking (surcharge) |
Hotel Jane sits in Santa Croce/Saude near Porta alla Croce, outside Florence’s ZTL for easier car access.
Choose Hotel Jane if you want lower walking time to some neighborhoods and easier car access outside the ZTL.
The Place Firenze is located on Piazza di Santa Maria Novella, steps from the basilica and close to Florence’s main attractions.
Pick The Place Firenze for the shortest walks to major sights and a central piazza address.
Hotel Jane offers modest, practical rooms in several small categories suitable for solo travelers, couples and families.
Hotel Jane is functional and family-oriented; expect simple rooms with essential amenities and flexible bedding options.
The Place Firenze is a small five-star hotel with a wider array of premium room and suite types, including lofts and penthouses.
The Place Firenze suits travelers who want more varied, higher-end room options and extra in-room amenities.
Hotel Jane runs an international buffet breakfast (surcharge) and a 24-hour bar/lounge for relaxed evenings.
Expect simple, affordable breakfast and an on-site bar; most full-service dining will be found nearby.
The Place Firenze provides a full-service restaurant, a bar/lounge, and limited-hours room service; breakfast is available for a fee.
The Place Firenze offers on-site restaurant and bar service geared toward a luxury stay; expect higher price points for breakfast and dining.
Hotel Jane does not have a pool; the property emphasizes urban access and practical services instead.
If a pool is important, Hotel Jane is not the right choice; it’s aimed at city exploration rather than on-site leisure facilities.
The Place Firenze highlights a rooftop terrace and city-view room types as key features.
The Place Firenze’s rooftop terrace and suite views are the closest equivalents to on-site leisure features; no pool is published.
Hotel Jane provides a 24-hour bar and nearby nightlife options in Santa Croce; no spa or gym on site.
Hotel Jane is fine for casual evenings and sightseeing; it doesn’t offer in-house wellness facilities.
The Place Firenze includes concierge-led services, a bar/lounge and access to a nearby fitness center; spa details are not published.
The Place Firenze offers more curated, higher-end evening experiences and concierge services; dedicated spa facilities are not published.

Hotel Jane — outside the ZTL with on-site/nearby paid parking and an EV charging station.

The Place Firenze — on Piazza Santa Maria Novella, steps from major attractions and short walks to the Duomo and Ponte Vecchio.

The Place Firenze — multiple suites, lofts and penthouses for a boutique five-star stay.

Hotel Jane — family- and pet-friendly policies plus straightforward rooms that accommodate groups.
The Place Firenze is closer — it’s on Piazza Santa Maria Novella and about 0.4 mi (0.7 km) from Piazza del Duomo; Hotel Jane is a longer walk (roughly 15–25 minutes).
Hotel Jane has no pool or spa. The Place Firenze lists a rooftop terrace and nearby fitness-center access; an on-site spa or pool is not published.
Hotel Jane is more convenient for drivers because it sits outside the ZTL and offers paid parking and EV charging; The Place Firenze offers valet parking for a surcharge but is in the historic center.
No. Both hotels accept guests of all ages; The Place Firenze is family-friendly and Hotel Jane explicitly welcomes families and pets.
Explore how Hotel Jane stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·