
Hotel Jane
Best for travelers who want hotel services (24-hour front desk, bar, concierge) and car access outside the ZTL.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Jane is a practical 3-star, family- and pet-friendly hotel near Porta alla Croce with a 24-hour front desk and a bar—good for travelers who want hotel services and easy car access outside Florence's ZTL. Sant'Antonino is a simple, centrally located guesthouse-style apartment property near the Duomo for travelers who prioritize location and basic self-catering space over hotel amenities.
Updated · about 1.1 km apart

Best for travelers who want hotel services (24-hour front desk, bar, concierge) and car access outside the ZTL.

Best for travelers who want a simple, central apartment-style base within a few minutes' walk of Florence’s main sights.
When Hotel Jane wins: choose Hotel Jane if you want the convenience of a staffed front desk, an on-site bar open 24 hours, concierge/tour help, and easier car access (outside the ZTL). It's geared toward families, pet owners, and guests who prefer hotel services.
When Sant'Antonino wins: choose Sant'Antonino if your priority is being as close as possible to the Duomo and main historic sights and having an apartment-style room with a small kitchen and terrace for basic self-catering.
Bottom line: both are practical Florence bases. Pick Hotel Jane for hotel conveniences and transport/parking ease; pick Sant'Antonino for a simpler, more central apartment experience and slightly shorter walks to key sights.
| Category | Hotel Jane | Sant'Antonino |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small 3-star hotel with staffed services, garden and bar. | Simple central apartment/guesthouse focused on location and basic amenities. |
| Location | Santa Croce/Saude near Porta alla Croce; outside ZTL so easy by car. | Via Sant 'Antonino, within a few minutes' walk of Piazza del Duomo and Santa Maria Novella. |
| Size (rooms) | 28 rooms (multiple sources; counts vary). | Not published |
| Room types | Standard or Room; Room (Piccola / Small); Economy Room, Balcony (Piccola / Small); Triple Room; Quadruple Room. | Apartment, 3 Bedrooms; Apartment. |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age references lead guest only. | |
| Pools | No pool. | |
| Restaurants & bars | 24-hour bar/lounge; buffet breakfast available for a surcharge. | No on-site restaurant or bar listed; self-catering kitchen in apartments. |
| Spa & fitness | No spa or fitness center. | |
| Known for | Hotel services, parking/EV charging and a 24-hour front desk. | Exceptionally central location within short walk of Duomo and Santa Maria Novella. |
| Wheelchair access | Not listed as wheelchair accessible; contact the hotel for specifics. | Wheelchair accessible – no (property lists 'Wheelchair accessible – no'). |
Hotel Jane sits in the Santa Croce/Saude area near Porta alla Croce and just outside Florence's ZTL.
Good choice if you want hotel access outside the restricted-traffic zone and don't mind a 15–25 minute walk to the Duomo.
Sant'Antonino is a very central apartment property on Via Sant 'Antonino, steps from major attractions.
Pick Sant'Antonino if proximity to Florence’s main sights is your top priority and you prefer walking everywhere.
Hotel Jane offers multiple small hotel room types designed for couples and families.
Hotel Jane provides standard hotel rooms in several occupancy formats with on-site hotel services.
Sant'Antonino lists apartment-style accommodations with kitchen facilities.
Sant'Antonino suits travelers who want a self-catering apartment and don't need on-site reception services.
Hotel Jane offers an on-site bar and a paid buffet breakfast; full restaurant info is mixed across sources.
Hotel Jane provides basic on-site dining and a 24-hour bar—useful after long sightseeing days.
Sant'Antonino is apartment-style with a kitchen; no on-site restaurant or bar is listed.
Sant'Antonino is best if you prefer to cook or eat out; it lacks hotel food & beverage services.
Neither property advertises a pool; Hotel Jane's signature practical amenity is on-site parking/EV charging and a garden.
Hotel Jane focuses on practical transport amenities and a small garden area rather than leisure facilities like pools.
Sant'Antonino does not list a pool; its key amenities are apartment kitchens and a terrace.
Sant'Antonino provides in-room cooking and outdoor terrace options instead of recreational facilities.
Hotel Jane has no spa or gym but offers a 24-hour bar and concierge/tour help for evening plans.
Choose Hotel Jane if you want a staffed property with an on-site bar and someone to help book evening plans.
Sant'Antonino lacks spa/gym facilities and nightlife services; its value is centrality to Florence's evening attractions.
Sant'Antonino places you within walking distance of Florence’s nightlife but provides no on-site evening facilities.

Hotel Jane — staffed 24-hour front desk, concierge/tour help, luggage storage and a 24-hour bar.

Sant'Antonino — extremely central, within about 0.4 mi (0.6 km) of the Duomo and minutes from Santa Maria Novella.

Sant'Antonino — apartments with kitchens, washing machine and terrace make it convenient for longer or independent stays.

Hotel Jane — located outside the ZTL with nearby private parking and an EV charging option.
Sant'Antonino is closer—listed at about 0.4 mi (0.6 km) from Piazza del Duomo; Hotel Jane is roughly a 15–25 minute walk to the Duomo.
No—neither Hotel Jane nor Sant'Antonino lists a pool or an on-site spa in the supplied information.
Sant'Antonino has no front desk; guests must contact the property at least 72 hours before arrival to arrange check-in and late arrivals may incur a fee.
Hotel Jane — it sits outside Florence's ZTL and lists nearby private parking and an EV charging station; Sant'Antonino is centrally located where street access is more restricted.
Explore how Hotel Jane stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·