
Hotel Jane
Best for travelers who want an affordable, walkable base near Florence's historic center with family- and pet-friendly policies.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Jane is a compact, 3-star, family- and pet-friendly base in the Santa Croce/Saude area for travelers who want simple rooms and easy access to Florence by foot or bike. Palazzo Firenze by Baglioni Hotels & Resorts is a luxury 5-star palazzo-style hotel near Santa Croce for travelers seeking full-service amenities and higher-end rooms in central Florence.
Updated · about 1.0 km apart

Best for travelers who want an affordable, walkable base near Florence's historic center with family- and pet-friendly policies.

Best for travelers who want a five-star palazzo experience with concierge services, on-site dining, and a higher guest-rating.
When Hotel Jane wins: choose Hotel Jane if you want a simple, lower-cost 3-star base that welcomes families and pets, is outside the ZTL (easier by car), and provides practical services like 24-hour front desk, bike rental and paid buffet breakfast.
When Palazzo Firenze by Baglioni Hotels & Resorts wins: pick the Baglioni property if you prefer five-star rooms (including suites), more onsite services (concierge, ticket/tour help, multiple room layouts with terraces), and a central palazzo setting close to Santa Croce and major museums.
Bottom line: Hotel Jane is a practical, budget-conscious choice for family and pet travelers who will spend most of their time sightseeing; Palazzo Firenze is for travelers wanting a higher-service, palazzo-style stay in the heart of Florence.
| Category | Hotel Jane | Palazzo Firenze by Baglioni Hotels & Resorts |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Simple, practical 3-star hotel | Luxury 5-star palazzo-style hotel |
| Location (neighborhood) | Santa Croce / Porta alla Croce area, outside ZTL | Santa Croce area (Via Ghibellina), steps from Basilica of Santa Croce |
| Size (rooms) | Small—around 24–34 rooms depending on source | Not published |
| Ages allowed | All ages welcome (family-friendly); lead guest minimum check-in age policies vary by source | All ages welcome (adultsOnly: false) |
| Pools | No pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Bar/lounge open 24 hours; buffet breakfast for a surcharge (breakfast room) | On-site restaurants, cafe and bar; free breakfast listed |
| Spa / wellness | No spa or fitness centre | Not published |
| Known for | Easy access to sights, pet-friendly and outside the ZTL (car-friendly) | Palazzo-style rooms, extensive guest services and concierge/ticketing |
| Accessibility & transport | Outside ZTL with onsite/nearby paid parking and EV charging; bus links to station | Central location with nearby parking options listed (car park charges may apply) |
Hotel Jane sits near Porta alla Croce, outside the ZTL, a 15–25 minute walk to the Duomo.
Good if you want easier car access and a short walk to Florence’s core.
Palazzo Firenze by Baglioni is positioned in central Florence near Basilica of Santa Croce.
Better if you want to be in the historic center with concierge help for last-minute plans.
Hotel Jane offers a small set of room types geared toward practical stays.
Expect straightforward, family-friendly rooms meant for sightseeing guests.
Palazzo Firenze provides a wider range of higher-end rooms and suites.
Greater choice and more space — useful for guests who want suite layouts or family-friendly suite options.
Hotel Jane keeps dining simple: a 24-hour bar and a paid buffet breakfast.
Good for casual evenings; most lunch/dinner choices are nearby.
Palazzo Firenze lists multiple on-site dining options including restaurants, a cafe and a bar.
Better if you prefer more on-site dining choices or in-house service for meals.
Hotel Jane does not offer a pool or beach access.
Not a pool hotel — plan city sightseeing rather than pool days.
Palazzo Firenze is a full-service 5-star city palazzo; on-site pool presence is not published in supplier listing.
This is a city palazzo focused on rooms and service rather than beach or pool access.
Hotel Jane offers limited on-site wellness and late-night options.
Choose Hotel Jane if you don’t need a spa or gym and will be out exploring by day.
Palazzo Firenze lists full-service amenities but a specific spa or wellness center isn’t published in supplier listing.
Expect higher service levels for planning nights out — confirm spa/wellness directly if essential.

Hotel Jane — family- and pet-friendly, modest rates, and outside the ZTL with nearby parking.

Palazzo Firenze by Baglioni — five-star rooms and suites, central palazzo setting and full-service amenities.

Palazzo Firenze by Baglioni — multiple on-site restaurants, cafe and bar listed by the supplier.

Hotel Jane — located outside the ZTL with private parking and EV charging nearby.
Palazzo Firenze by Baglioni is very near Basilica of Santa Croce (about 0.18 km from the basilica); Hotel Jane is about 1.2 km from Santa Croce.
Hotel Jane does not have a pool or a spa. The supplier listing for Palazzo Firenze does not publish a pool or a named spa in the provided amenities; confirm directly with the hotel if a spa or pool is essential.
Hotel Jane is outside the ZTL with nearby private parking and EV charging, which makes it easier for guests arriving by car; Palazzo Firenze lists car park options but is in a central location that may be subject to ZTL restrictions.
Palazzo Firenze’s supplier data lists the property as adultsOnly: false and includes family/child-friendly amenities; the hotel also accepts pets (charges may apply).
Explore how Hotel Jane stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·